A quick review of SIAC, Mumbai. State Institute for Administrative Careers or SIAC is the only well known UPSC coaching option in Mumbai.
Positives:
1) good library. any book that isn't available too is made available for students fairly quick
2) well lit reading hall
3) Group Discussions. the only and biggest advantage SIAC has to offer is that it connects you with other aspirants. it is upto you to identify the serious aspirants whom you want to talk to or keep in touch with. For example, there is a 6pm daily news reading/group discussion session which goes on. This is a student-driven model. (ie, institute plays no role. ) anybody can join that.
4) stipend - whenever it is paid ! (lot of problems in this.)
5) good access to Delhi's resources. you can get access to most of the materials, books, test series, question papers, MAGAZINES, etc which you get in delhi right here in Mumbai. generally not available anywhere else in mumbai. but you get these at SIAC. by resources i mean people as well. the students who come there too.
6) networking with good students. many who come there are sincere or bright. (though there are the non serious as well. but less compared to delhi, in my opinion.) it is possible for you to get a healthy competitive network, if you want. (i prefer to read alone)
Negatives:
1) premises and facilities are not very well maintained. dusty. sometimes the place really needs very good cleaning.
2) Irregular lectures. History and Maths (for the prelims batch) teachers are good, rest are okay or bad. History by Bhushan Deshmukh sir is excellent though - better than Delhi. But please note that SIAC isn't really about the coaching. It's about the support system that it tries to provide students. More of an enabler role.
3) We're trying to request classes for mains! yet to start.
4) stipends are very very very late. Right now nearly 5 months' stipend is due. Do not depend or plan anything based on the stipends!
Conclusions :
SIAC is not much about the coaching or coaching quality. What it manages is to give you access to a variety of UPSC-related things, (which you otherwise will never get in Mumbai). It is more of a voluntary group study model or networking opportunity if you are looking for one. I prefer to use it for the reading hall and library facilities.
I have already posted the SIAC entrance question paper here
Here is their result declaration link
Positives:
1) good library. any book that isn't available too is made available for students fairly quick
2) well lit reading hall
3) Group Discussions. the only and biggest advantage SIAC has to offer is that it connects you with other aspirants. it is upto you to identify the serious aspirants whom you want to talk to or keep in touch with. For example, there is a 6pm daily news reading/group discussion session which goes on. This is a student-driven model. (ie, institute plays no role. ) anybody can join that.
4) stipend - whenever it is paid ! (lot of problems in this.)
5) good access to Delhi's resources. you can get access to most of the materials, books, test series, question papers, MAGAZINES, etc which you get in delhi right here in Mumbai. generally not available anywhere else in mumbai. but you get these at SIAC. by resources i mean people as well. the students who come there too.
6) networking with good students. many who come there are sincere or bright. (though there are the non serious as well. but less compared to delhi, in my opinion.) it is possible for you to get a healthy competitive network, if you want. (i prefer to read alone)
Negatives:
1) premises and facilities are not very well maintained. dusty. sometimes the place really needs very good cleaning.
2) Irregular lectures. History and Maths (for the prelims batch) teachers are good, rest are okay or bad. History by Bhushan Deshmukh sir is excellent though - better than Delhi. But please note that SIAC isn't really about the coaching. It's about the support system that it tries to provide students. More of an enabler role.
3) We're trying to request classes for mains! yet to start.
4) stipends are very very very late. Right now nearly 5 months' stipend is due. Do not depend or plan anything based on the stipends!
Conclusions :
SIAC is not much about the coaching or coaching quality. What it manages is to give you access to a variety of UPSC-related things, (which you otherwise will never get in Mumbai). It is more of a voluntary group study model or networking opportunity if you are looking for one. I prefer to use it for the reading hall and library facilities.
I have already posted the SIAC entrance question paper here
Here is their result declaration link
